Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> You see, Emacs has been around for 50 years. Very few software projects get to live this long

This!

I think about this often, and yes Emacs is one, and I’d put Debian as a whole on that list too.

Once Emacs clicks as a philosophy (tl;dr: it’s not just an editor, it’s YOUR editor) it’s a whole new world.

It’s been interesting lately for me - playing with different harnesses, I’ve found pi.dev to have this same philosophy - the provide you a canvass and you have to find your own paint and brushes to create a masterpiece

 help



I tried to get to emacs several times, always got bored after trying to configure it. It takes a huge effort to make it your editor. However the fact that you can run claude inside it and has access to its entire state, can make changes to the environment live is really a game changer. It even converts some textual apps to emacs native stuff and it is mind blowing.

Emacs is a user-customizable environment with a text editor. At one point you could do everything in Emacs and I frequently did.

In many ways Emacs was both ahead of its time and continuously behind it. It never quite transitioned to the post-1995 GUI/web based world and held onto too much of the past. The core idea is however timeless and my hope has always been that someone will reinvent it for the 21st century.


To claim that Emacs didn't transition to the GUI world is inaccurate. With the transition to modern graphical toolkits it got extensive styling and multilingual support, including BIDI and Harfbuzz-enabled text shaping. Menus were present and powerful already when I started using it in the late 1990s. Image support has been there for long years, and recently there have been strides in canvas with all kinds of whiz-bang graphical stuff.

> my hope has always been that someone will reinvent it for the 21st century

Atom was supposed to be that. In a way, Firefox in the days of XUL was.

> It never quite transitioned to the post-1995 GUI/web based world

What do you think it should do in order to do that? What is graphical Emacs missing today, or (worse) what is paradigmatically wrong with it?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: