That seems like a different reason for him to be fired. If he had a competent boss, I could see that happening, but not with Trump as president. Trump is all about reality TV. He probably wishes more of his cabinet and department heads made it.
Why do you want him to stay? You seem to be awfully keen to defend a man who isn't doing his job and allowed a major ATC failure to occur on his watch. You're all over this thread defending a useless man.
I don’t care if he stays or goes. I care that others, particularly in a forum of engineers (who are supposedly more intelligent than most) are demanding his head for the wrong reasons.
It’s stupid to fire engineers for accidentally causing operational incidents, and it’s similarly stupid to fire their bosses unless they intentionally or negligently set the stage to increase the risk of serious incidents. Mistakes are the fertilizer that bears the fruit of wisdom and experience.
Meanwhile, people here think Jensen Huang should be allowed to return to the helm at Nvidia even though doing so would be about the stupidest act the board could take; doing so would put the entire company at even greater risk of criminal liability.
I went through the whole thread and I totally agree with you. Regardless of anything else, unless there are proper processes in place, blaming an individual becomes just theater. The overall goal for any system failure should be to improve the process, unless the failure was intentional or due to negligence.
I think it is silly to not fire people and yet expect people to still learn from the mistake. If the only downside to taking down the nations ATC is some lawyer composed response, why would anyone be more careful about it in the future? Why wouldn't they take it as a sign that they could play it even faster and looser in the future if there is no downside to them?
Ive never made a mistake that costs more than I am worth, so no. I would expect if I made a mistake costing millions of dollars or more I would be fired.
I wouldn’t expect that. Your employer is going to discuss whether you have learned from your mistake and determine what changes to make to reduce the probability of it happening again. They’re unlikely to fire you, only to replace you with someone who could end up making a similar or worse mistake because they haven’t lived your experience yet.
If he leaves maybe Trump would hire a competent replacement instead (unlikely, but can't be much worse than the current Cabinet of Clowns).