Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Suppose you have a law that says that in order to build new multi-unit housing, a given percentage of the new units have to be affordable housing and have to be built within reasonable distance of a transit stop in the same town. Meanwhile you have a town with poor mass transit and very little land zoned for multi-unit housing, and none of it overlaps. In other words, you're both required to and prohibited from building new affordable housing units near a transit stop. Which means you also can't build the other units.
 help



I thought one law could not force you to break another?

Which law are you breaking if you build no housing whatsoever?

Notice that there are many cases of this where that kind of outcome is what you want, e.g. if there is a law against operating e-bikes above 20 MPH and a law against going below 40 MPH on the freeway and the de facto result is "no e-bikes on the freeway" then that's a pretty reasonable outcome.

Whereas "no new housing" is a presumably unintended absurdity, but that doesn't mean you're guaranteed a way out of it.

There are also many cases where rather than being required to do something impossible you're required to do something infeasible, which in practice is the same thing but then they get to point to the entire mountain of shit you'd be required to eat and suggest that you do that.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: