I am part of the problem and recently started turning them on after realizing they were proving to be very useful inputs when using chatbots with connectors to tools that can see the transcripts. It's made scribing notes mostly a ritual and not a practical benefit.
Before I turned it on I asked my team if they had any objections. Silence for eight seconds before saying if anyone was uncomfortable objecting in the group they could reach out to me individually. No one ever did. The only request was that everyone internal get copied on the notes so they could correct them if needed.
These are company decisions to have these connectors and privacy choices. It's their data and their risk. There has never been an illusion that anything said, written, or done at work is private from the company. At home I partake in none of this.
> Before I turned it on I asked my team if they had any objections.
Did you check with internal counsel?
> There has never been an illusion that anything said, written, or done at work is private from the company
The entire industry is one court case away from banning transcription. Not many companies want every word of every meeting legally discoverable - in the past, meetings were used to avoid having a written record. The implications of ubiquitous transcriptions haven't percolated yet, I give 1-3 years (or until the next major case)
This is all of course sanctioned by leadership and the teams who have standing (legal, IT, cybersecurity). Just because something is allowed doesn't mean I'll opt to do it. If I worked somewhere that hasn't been using corporate spyware on all employee laptops and face recognition around the building since long before auto transcription came in vogue I might feel differently about the decision to embrace the surveillance for productivity.
I don't have the authority to make the meaningful decisions, just to do my job efficiently.
Leadership sanctions, and sub teams make their own rules (out of convenience).
If you have the AI notetaker button available to mass employees, and don't want it used, then your GC is not protecting you or they're expecting you to ask for forgiveness.
Without someone openly object to it, and without the trust that I can tell you I am objecting to it without the fear of being asked why and what am I hiding from. The Norm would be no one speaks up, and knowing it is recorded it means there can't be a honest and candid conversation behind close doors. And the tone of the meeting on long term will shift.
>done at work is private from the company.
That is why we have phone call, face to face meetings and email. Things are black and white for a reason because I want it to be recorded. If everything I said is going to be on record I will now be very careful of what comes out of my month.
In an already toxic work environment, this will likely make things even worst.
> There has never been an illusion that anything said, written, or done at work is private from the company.
There has also never been an illusion that anything said in public is private from the government yet I hope you can see that technologies that allow mass surveillance make for a very different society.
You think they could find something with a neutered transcript and there's precedent that someone can infer the LLM reasoning for a proprietary frontier model?
a. This seems hand wavy. I assume people are already taking discoverable notes on company assets even for "casual" calls.
b. What's your experience with enterprise AI meeting note takers? My experience is that they're setup to summarize and won't give verbatim accounts. Not "tape recorders". In my experience, they neutralize a lot of inflammatory language that I would've otherwise put in my meeting minutes.
Hand wavy? Upthread is talking about transcripts of meetings, not summaries, and my simple, uncomplex response was clear. What are you even talking about?
Apparently you disagree. OK, thanks, see you later?!
> Upthread is talking about transcripts of meetings
And AI notetakers along with parsing the transcripts using bots/connectors, which also doesn't mean the transcripts are persisted. You didn't distinguish either.
FWIW, it's a core premise of the article:
> These tools still often use a microphone to capture raw audio from conversations and convert it into summaries or transcripts before discarding the audio.
The next problem is going to be having to opt into the headless ones to reduce friction around adding your notetaker
I don’t particularly want to, for both ethics reasons and the fact my headed one (Fathom) is good enough. But it’s getting annoying to have inconsistent notes
Before I turned it on I asked my team if they had any objections. Silence for eight seconds before saying if anyone was uncomfortable objecting in the group they could reach out to me individually. No one ever did. The only request was that everyone internal get copied on the notes so they could correct them if needed.
These are company decisions to have these connectors and privacy choices. It's their data and their risk. There has never been an illusion that anything said, written, or done at work is private from the company. At home I partake in none of this.