Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Whose idea was HTTP/2 anyway

An advertising company

Later joined by CDNs

But www users were not consulted

"HTTP/2 is largely based on Google's experimental SPDY protocol, which was first announced in November 2009 as an internal project to increase the speed of the web."

https://blog.cloudflare.com/introducing-http2

"[I]ncrease the speed of the web" at what cost

The easiest way to "increase the speed of the web" is to reduce or eliminate data collection, surveillance and advertising-related garbage from websites

With HTTP/1.1 I get speeds that are faster than HTTP/2; I don't make requests for ads, tracking or telemetry

What is the "mitigation" for Apache's HTTP/2 failure

"2. Implement Temporary Mitigation

If immediate patching is not possible due to operational constraints, temporarily disable HTTP/2 support to eliminate the attack vector.

Edit the configuration file (such as httpd.conf) to restrict active protocols to HTTP/1.1 by removing h2 and h2c references:"

   # Restrict protocols to HTTP/1.1
   Protocols http/1.1
One "security researcher" tried to suggest "HTTP/1.1 must die"

His reason was not "speed" it was "security" problems with CDNs

As above, the (bogus) "justification" given for HTTP/2 wasn't "security" it was "speed of the web"

CDNs cannot implement HTTP/1.1

Apache cannot implement HTTP/2

Without the data collection, surveillance and ads, HTTP/1.1 is faster than HTTP/2 according to own tests

HTTP/2 came from internet advertising companies and "CDNs", HTTP/1.1 came from academics

As a www user, that's what I care about

 help



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: