Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I doubt any rare valuable book is being destroyed. If a book were valuable, it would make sense to scan it non-destructively. This is especially the case for old rare books that are long out of copyright; the copyright motivation for not keeping the original copy around does not exist.

The books being destroyed as so worthless they're bought in bulk and were destined for junking anyway, like the 600 million books that are destroyed each year just in the US. At least as pulp they can contribute something of slight value.

Here's a way these old supposed valuable books can get a new life. Go wild! Prices start at $12.99 per linear foot. This clearly demonstrates the value society assigns to these precious rectangular prisms of inked cellulose.

https://booksbythefoot.com/

I have a sneaking suspicion the whole tempest-in-a-teapot was astroturfed by publishers who were miffed at the courts looking favorably on scanning for AI training.

 help



If I were a not so good guy running an AI company and I got my hands on a valuable book, I would scan the book and destroy the paper copy. This way, others won't scan that knowledge for themselves and would have to come to my company to get access to the knowledge and only crumbs of that knowledge at my discretion.

Yes there are people who have this psychology.


I thought the book destruction is due to copyright law. Its very easy, change copyright law if you don't want books destroyed after scanning. Why are ypu blaming Anthropic for following copyright law?

Since my comment elsewhere in the thread. These projects are largely trying to crawl the entire ISBN space, and this includes rare but worth-saving books printed in small runs (scholarly works, books on local history, etc.); that they can be bought for cheap says little about the exclusiveness of the info within them, as the booksellers pricing them probably have little or no knowledge of the respective field.

As for "old rare books out of copyright", those generally predate ISBNs and so are not being so mercilessly crawled by semi-automated means.


> that they can be bought for cheap says little about the exclusiveness of the info within them, as the booksellers pricing thdm probably have little or no knowledge of the respective field.

No professional bookseller today is pricing a book that they aren't familiar with without putting the ISBN into a bookseller search and finding out the market price. The hunting booksellers have dedicated PDAs that will scan the UPC on the back, and speak the current price into earbuds for quick searching at charity book sales.


I don't think you are aware of just how many kinds of books are assigned an ISBN number, and so will get hit by a project crawling the whole numerical space.

Within my own (non-destructive!) scanning contributions for the shadow libraries, I have gone through innumerable ISBN-issued books from Eastern Europe and the former USSR printed in very small runs, often 50-100 copies. When one of those few copies finds its way to a used-bookseller, it is usually priced very low: it doesn't look attractive to a general audience, there is no agreed "market price from a bookseller search" because maybe no other seller has ever seen it, and the bookseller doesn't know that it holds exclusive information that some scholars would prefer be saved.


So if one cannot easily determine if these books are valuable, how do you propose they would be saved from the vast stream of books constantly being destroyed? Isn't their value conditional on this identification already having been performed?

This is interesting. Similar to the problem of having a Van Gogh in 1890 when it's worth nothing in price. You can reasonably say:

It's taking up space. It's not fashionable, and it looks kind of ugly to me. Who's Doctor Gachet anyway? I can't predict that anybody will ever want this. So, I'll throw it away.

But you can also reasonably say:

It's not taking up much space. Fashions change along with culture and ideas. I like paintings. People like paintings generally. I can't predict that nobody will ever want this. So, I'll keep it.

I conclude that if you're willing to be an archivist, you're doing good, and somebody somewhere should be willing to be an archivist. Ideally several people. This doesn't depend on the price of items at time of archiving.


I've seen these guys in operation!

The construction of roads can use about 45,000 books per mile.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: