Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yes, we are, because it's a non-problem.
 help



Calling permanent destruction of rare books, and actively reducing the pool of human knowledge, a "non-problem" is about as rational as those people who burnt rare artworks after "converting" them to NFTs.

The rarity of a book doesn't actually tell you much about the value of the information within. Many rare books are practically worthless, and get destroyed all the time by institutions like libraries.

Nothing reveals the value of information. New purposes for old information arise unexpectedly. For each purpose, or person, other people's assessment of value is wrong. Books destroyed by libraries are often books I wanted. Space constraints are tragic.

My 2nd grade math workbook is one of a kind. It's the only math workbook I wrote in second grade. It's worthless.

Some future historian might like to see what my generation learned in second grade math but for that they just need a sample, not mine specifically.


This is a totally imaginary issue. Countless "rare books" are thrown away every day.

1. Why is "rare books" in quotes,

2. How do you know,

3. How many is countless,

4. So what?


> Why is "rare books" in quotes,

Because the implications that the rarity of said books makes them valuable is entirely unsupported.

> 2. How do you know,

Nearly 2 million books are destroyed each day in the US. Are you asserting not one of them is rare?


So, some books that are rare are not valuable, but we can't know which ones, and it's not an imaginary issue.

How do you know "two million", by the way?


Sorry, I misremembered, it was 320 million books/year, so nearly 1 million/day, not 2 million.

Where did you find this out?


OK. That cites this 2009 report: https://nepis.epa.gov/Exe/ZyNET.exe/P100A0NX.txt?ZyActionD=Z... where page 47 has a table, with 640 thousand tons of books added to landfill in 2009, along with a slightly greater weight of magazines.

So, does this make the destruction of books to feed AI a non-problem? Is the loss of printed information to landfill completely fine and not regrettable? The loss of books to AI is on top of the loss to landfill, and seeks out books somewhat methodically, which means a bias toward rare books, compared to obtaining books by weight.

The argument goes like this, I suppose: some percentage of the 640 thousand tons of landfill books (or whatever this year's figure is) were rare, but unwanted. Therefore, because some rare books are unwanted, and some unwanted books are not valuable, the rare books that were methodically bought to feed AI were kind of sort of going to go to landfill anyway, and nothing of value was lost.


> Is the loss of printed information to landfill completely fine and not regrettable? The loss of books to AI is on top of the loss to landfill, and seeks out books somewhat methodically, which means a bias toward rare books, compared to obtaining books by weight.

I think you may be overestimating how many books are being scanned and shredded in addition to being sent to landfill, rather than instead of being sent to landfill.

Having a collection of some few hundred rare books, some of them dating back to the 1700s, the market value of these things are extremely low. They’re bulky, they’re fragile, and there aren’t a lot of buyers. I literally couldn’t give them away to booksellers or libraries (I tried!) except for specific items that had nominal value (in the tens of dollars) and were relatively desirable.

As a book lover, I wish this wasn’t happening as well. But as someone with some knowledge of the book world, these AI companies are only able to buy these things at economical rates because nobody wants them.

They’re also presumably not purchasing many copies of the same book (the goal is to scan them, redundancy beyond a few copies doesn’t help much) so I don’t think this will have some major impact on the overall world knowledge. Anything they’re buying has more copies in circulation or is so niche as to be undesirable by buyers/collectors.


The fact that nobody will pay for them is not a persuasive argument that they're garbage.

There's a similar issue in archeology. There's no monetary value in preserving the ancient mound with (somewhat) fascinating relics of early culture,* apart from robbing it of any gold or items that could be auctioned. The mound is like your 300-year-old unsaleable books of niche interest.

I say "no value", but that's contradicted by "fascinating". So it's more like there's no readily available path to monetizing the preservation of a rare item. In principle it ought to be worth something, because people are interested, but the difficulty of actually preserving it defeats that interest (and destroys the price).

*including perhaps literal ancient garbage, now of interest. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxyrhynchus_Papyri


It’s not an argument that they’re garbage. The argument is that if you’re a bookseller, you have to manage and cull inventory to remain profitable because physical space is a limiting factor.

Finding someone who wants books which may be rare but are not broadly market-desirable is hard. Hard enough that I literally couldn’t give them away.

When Anthropic calls you up and says “I’ll take these off of your hands and I’ll even pay you for them”, you probably take it.

In a capitalist economy the only alternative to rich companies buying these and doing as they please with them is someone else buying them who pledges not to destroy them.

Edit: now a good question here might be why universities, many of them rich, aren’t offering to take these instead. it would be much better if they did.

when I contacted UBC about some of my books, they said they had a backlog and it’d take a lot of time and effort so I’d need to catalogue each in detail and send them the list first. I didn’t have the time so I didn’t, but they do have the resources if they choose to employ them.


I live near a university. They are increasingly putting physical books into archival storage, you know those library shelves on rollers that are normally jammed right up against each other. These are in remote buildings.

Current books and journals are increasingly in electronic form, accessible via license from publishers for use by the university community. The libraries that formerly had stacks of shelves one could browse have mostly been repurposed.


> So, does this make the destruction of books to feed AI a non-problem?

It makes fatuous declarations of the sanctity of books be obviously absurd.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: