It seems they are not going to give in to the demand from unions in Germany. To prove their point, they are announcing the consequences of having a workforce that is overpaid and no longer know what real work feels like. German workers need that wake up call if they don’t want to become a third world country.
A quick google shows they make about 45k/year (pre-tax). Even for Germany that is not a lot of money. That is less than the median Germany salary. Mercedes is asking them to work 40h/week without an increase in monthly pay. Who would accept that without a fight? Mercedes does not build cheap cars, I am sure they can afford reasonable pay. Have you worked in car manufacturing? Do you know what "real work" feels like?
That may well be true, but they don't have to compete with median german salaries, they have to compete with eastern European/Chinese ones (where a lot of car production already is).
And a factory worker in China makes <$20k/year, and will be easily convinced to work longer than 35h/week.
You still need a bunch of wage-slaves to plan, build, maintain and operate the facilities, even if actual production is 100% automated. And nothing prevents your lower-wage competition from just copying the most efficient automation pieces, only there's less pressure on them to do so, and they stay more flexible with their cheap labor pool.
The thing that actually helps is wages in China rising to a somewhat competitive level, but that takes time.
It's not an issue of how much anyone feels they ought to be paid.
German automakers are simply shifting production to eastern Europe, where there are skilled autoworkers who will happily make cars for 4X less the cost of labor vs. German labor.
No, that analysis is wrong. You try to blame it on the workers.
While it is true that the work cost is higher than in Poland, even
though Poland closed the gap immensely in the last 10 years, the
issue is much more deeply rooted. There is no way Germany can now
compete with China. This happened to the USA too, decades before,
see how Detroit collapsed. China kind of copied the Japanese and South Korean variant while massively upsizing all of that, including integrating key aspects into their work flows. You only need to look at robot factories. You won't find that in Germany much at all. The innovation changed completely.
Mercedes-Benz just tries to shift the blame to lower costs, which
is understandable from their point of view, but does not fix the
core problem. Even building in Poland or Romania, won't fix the
issue with regards to China. That's not the fault of the workers
primarily.
I'm relatively certain Detroit collapsed because their vehicles were junk. The entire reason why 70s era vehicles are so easy to keep running today, is it took just as much work back then to keep them going.
By stopping import of Russian gas, yes, there is no way to compete with China.
Imported natural gas used to cost Germany roughly €12 per megawatt-hour (MWh) at the border
Now wholesale prices have climbed to around €60+ per MWh, roughly FIVE times higher than previous levels.
That's goodbye to Industry in Germany - well except for the War Industry which has state protection and funding and doesn't need to be competitive. And China has become even more cheaper since they pay far less for Russian gas.
I don't know why the very bright guys here on HN have such HARD blinkers on correlation and causation between energy prices and energy-intensive industry. Even Merz himself finally admitted it this year but most HN posters want to put their high-IQ heads into cement rather than admit that stopping Russian gas was one the main causes of the downfall of German industry.
This is true. Firing lazy workers are super difficult here. So the wage doesn't move and people with a cushy job do whatever the hell they want without any consequences.
Workers shouldnt have to live poorly so you can buy a cheap German car. The reality as the GDP goes up and wealth and wages go up, you can no longer compete in manufacturing compared to poorer countries. This is how capitalism works. Blaming the workers is entirely wrong. Everyone who works should have a good wage. Germany is just experiencing what the US experienced 20-30 years ago when it admitted its best moving a lot of manufacturing overseas. Near everything you own is made in these poorer countries, but that's not a problem, but somehow when it comes to cars, people take offense.
Until we achieve worldwide socialism where it doesnt matter what is made where, this is how its going to be. National borders will dictate economics and what is best done in those countries. The wealthy west simply cannot compete on manufacturing anymore.
> Workers shouldnt have to live poorly so you can buy a cheap German car.
Have you looked at the prices of German cars? Nobody ever called them cheap. Germany exports mostly luxury vehicles, while paying their workers a pittance. As China car manufacturers move up the quality scale, they will eat up whatever marketshare German cars have.
yes for sure it's the fault of the lazy overpaid workers not the decisions made by management. and this germany has to wake up narrative is the same that comes from the right wing politicians. so i would call this bs.