Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Article is pay walled but if the headline is true that's tragic. I wonder if they're going to invest elsewhere or just admit defeat and slowly wind down the business.

I can't help but think this was influenced somewhat by the shutdown of Germany's nuclear reactors thus making energy more expensive and all the knock on effects.

 help



Mercedes-Benz turned a net profit of $5.3 billion last year. Even if they had had a bad year, they would have assets - tangible and intangible - and potential for turning things around. There's plenty of stakeholders with, well, stakes in the business and incentives to see it do well.

How does one come to wonder if they are going to "slowly wind down the business"?


"We're stopping investing in the business" is usually synonymous with "growth ran out and we have no idea what to do besides hope and pray and eventually go bankrupt"

basically, management is in a standoff with the unions about working more than 35 hours without paying for it, they also don't want to pay holiday bonuses.

Citing high production costs, they are looking to the US and want to bring costs in Germany down to the production costs in the US.

Nothing about what cuts the management is willing to take.


> Citing high production costs, they are looking to the US and want to bring costs in Germany down to the production costs in the US.

Which is funny since both are much higher than China. These lagging car industries will only be able to be protected for so long from Chinese EVs like BYD.


Its also not the cost of energy. Mercedes bet big on the US and Chinese markets and the got hit with the tariffs and the economic downturn in china.

I do have a new CLA EV from them and I think they actually have a good platform there, great range and surprisingly affordable compared to other Mercedes cars.

But it is about 5 years too late.


> I can't help but think this was influenced somewhat by the shutdown of Germany's nuclear reactors thus making energy more expensive and all the knock on effects.

The shutdown had no effect on energy prices in Germany.



Yeah, the paywall is questionable - I don't think I'd read them enough to be worth paying the price even though I understand they need to make money...

My bet (edit: reading other comments I'm glad I didn't put money on it... leaving this comment anyway) based on other cases of this is they are fighting a law (or several laws), and are making this threat as a "change the law to favor us or we will leave and this prove you need us more than we need you".

I don't know how it will work out for them, I've seen it go both ways. I've also seen this stop some really stupid laws, and also stop some really good laws. Without knowing details of what they are trying to do I can't comment on which side I support.


MB is complaining that they can't force the union workers to work longer days without extra pay. They are also complaining that Chinese automakers are selling well in Europe and are much cheaper to build. The second complaint is completely valid, I don't see how domestic auto making can survive when you can pick up a BYD for much less.

I think that energy prices are just a part of the root cause.

The other parts are:

1. German producers really fucked up with the "electric" revolution and were caught a bit with their pants down by Tesla and especially the Chinese brands.

2. Specific to Mercedes-Benz, I believe the brand failed to attract younger buyers. Personally, I associate Mercedes cars with boomers/older genX folks.

3. Price. In a moment in which affordability is a major issue for the majority of people, the base model of the cheapest car (the A class) starts from 42900 CHF.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: