Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The US was in the right place at the right time, yes.

It was still mostly agrarian pre-WW2. Post-WW2 it was orders of magnitude more industrialized. Still, it wasn’t until the 60’s that the majority of the population was no longer living in rural areas and working on farms.

China’s fuckup was much deeper, as their ‘peasants to industry’ roadmap didn’t exist, and just consisted of telling every peasant to make their own forge (essentially) and start making heavy industrial goods. Which of course not only resulted in shitty or non-existent industrial goods, but also widespread famine because they stopped focused on growing crops.

They also completely cut out Capital, and they’d already targeted and destroyed most private industrial conglomerates (and anyone who knew how to build or run one) due to ideology.

The US didn’t have those issues, so when the time came they threw money and a command economy at the existing Industrial base and grew it leaps and bounds almost overnight.

The large quantity of low cost, available, and relatively mobile workers - and excess industrial capacity - due to the Great Depression and it’s after effects helped too.

 help



> It was still mostly agrarian pre-WW2.

This is categorically false. About 20% of the US labor force was engaged in farm labor in the 1930s. Keep in mind that, given concomitant unemployment numbers, this means there is nearly as many unemployed US people as there are farmers.

Does that sound like a "mostly agrarian" economy to you?


1 in 5 working adults literally in the fields? you bet. Guess what the ratio is now? 1.5%, or as the 70’s, about 1 to 22.

That number at the time (21.5%, btw) only counts folks directly working on the farm, not all the secondary folks - butchers, bakers, flour mill workers, etc.

Currently in the US, the 1.5% working directly on farms then leads to ~ 10.5% of additional employment going ‘farm to table’. Not counting restaurants and the like, but all the middle folks and value add folks.

[https://www.statista.com/statistics/1316855/us-farm-nonfarm-...]

Late 1800’s to pre-1930’s, direct farm labor was as high as 53% - but that was also because there wasn’t much value add. There was a lot of subsidence farming, and people often ate what was produced locally due to poor transportation infrastructure.

That started to change with automation and the railroads, with a very large multiple of the economy being about processing, transporting, etc. the food produced by farms. Think the milkman, butchers and meat processing plants, textile mills, etc. It’s what made Chicago the powerhouse it was, for instance.

that is still part of the agrarian economy.


US might have been 20% agrarian prior to WWII; but Germany still had 30% of their workforce employed in agriculture.

and that changes what I said how?

By adding valuable global context for how much more industrialized the US was than its contemporaries prior to WWII.

then you should include actual context. but it would refute your point eh?

the Nazi’s rose to power using agricultural jobs programs starting in the 30’s, because the financial collapse caused by reparations and hyperinflation (followed by the great depression!) mostly impacted the cities and industrial centers. unemployment in some years topped 26% or more during that time period.

This also encouraged rigging the numbers, and every analysis I’ve found for german labor force types/censuses points out the data is basically all hot garbage during that time. one set of data even shows 76% (!!!) agricultural workforce participation during part of the period which is wild, and clearly impossible.

none of this has much to do with actual industrial production capability, as those factories largely sat idle while this all played out. post-WW1 treaties forbade most of the interesting heavy industrial stuff. building large capital equipment in a hyperinflationary environment is begging to go bankrupt. even building ships was heavily restricted by tonnage, arms were heavily restricted, etc.

the Nazi’s were so popular in Germany because they eventually just said ‘fuck it’, and started building them anyway - but then lied and hid they were doing so. again making the industrial numbers highly suspect.

one thing is for certain - post WW1 german industrial output had nothing to do with their physical ability to produce, and everything to do with their being completely fucked in 5 different other ways.


« rigging the numbers »

Excellent point about how "a rigorous quantitative approach based on official documents" can lead to wrong results and flawed conclusions… :)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: