Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Who are the people who are responsibly writing all this test code but declare loudly on Twitter that no one needs to read the production code?
 help



The test code is written and checked by AI without humans needing to be the ones looking at it.

soooo wouldn't that be exactly the "deskilling" being discussed here, and isn't that deskilling concerning for money-handling firms?

having seen both (a) mission-critical human-built systems become nightmares for maintainability and extensibility and (b) bleeding-edge ai coding agents confidently and quickly fix a wrong problem in the face of an issue (or fix it in a slightly wrong way), I remain skeptical that this great de-skilling will all be perfectly fine.

of course, if you aren't looking at the code you won't fucking know until someone yells...


I disagree with several premises of the article. There is not going to be human led investigations of outages. People do not need to train on easy outages to be able to handle hard outages. Even if you wanted to train people on easy outages AI makes it easier than ever to setup up real world like issues to replace the need for real world experience. I also disagree in labeling it deskilling when it is a reallocation of skills to what is actually needed.

>concerning for money-handling firms

The real world is robust. It's okay for money handling code to have bugs. It's not the end of the world and AI will be able to have a lower bug rate than humans.


> The real world is robust. It's okay for money handling code to have bugs.

This is true. The world will go on. But your business will lose more money than it gained by not paying attention to the code. It will lose money because it will have to compensate customers or lose customers. That's how the world maintains it's robustness.


Your business competes against other businesses. If hand written code is superior, that business will win.

I've seen some terrible AI-written tests. You have to check that code too. You have to check all the code.



Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: