Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Do you think picket lines are illegal?

Picket lines that actually block other people from crossing instead of trying to persuade them not to? Yes. Use of threats, physically blocking, or just general impediment? Yes.

Not only does it violate state law (e.g. obstruction of free movement, interference with a business open to the public, false imprisonment, and assault are all offenses here in California depending on the facts), but it also violates NLRA rules.

(e.g. a recent labor case found repeated 1 to 4 minute "inadvertent" blockages unlawful -- https://www.laborrelationslawinsider.com/2018/02/the-nlrb-si...)

The Moscone Act that recognizes picketing federally also makes clear that this is not OK.

> It is not the intent of this section to permit conduct that is unlawful including breach of the peace, disorderly conduct, the unlawful blocking of access or egress to premises where a labor dispute exists, or other similar unlawful activity.

 help



> obstruction of free movement, interference with a business open to the public, false imprisonment, and assault

thing is, those all apply to a person. if a person is in the robot then it makes sense. If a person is driving the robot remotely then it gets blurry. If it's autonomous then none of those seem to apply, the robot has no right of free movement.


Yes-- my takes on it in the case of a delivery robot are elsewhere in thread. This is specifically addressing a person who said:

> 1A says she is free to protest human workers by getting in their way in public.

And the answer is, no, the first amendment does not let you block people and prevent them from proceeding in their work or other activities.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: