Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Open source projects have insane levels of gatekeeping nowadays.

It’s sad, but also makes some sense.

Nobody wants to maintain someone else’s AI slop when they could do their own version of the slop.

 help



> insane levels of gatekeeping

Good! I want to be able to trust and rely on homebrew, authorization, authentication, infra, os and other _crucial_ software. The bar should be really high and I appreciate the efforts of open source maintainers now more than ever.


I didn’t say it was bad, my response was to a question asking why this wasn’t a pull request for homebrew.

Consider not using loaded words then

Oh it is gatekeeping :)

Everyone doing any kind of gatekeeping is convinced that it’s for a great reason.


> Oh it is gatekeeping

That's exactly the problem with loaded words. People often use it to mean different things.

For example, in open source software, "open" has a different meaning than it does in "open door". It never meant that anyone could upstream their desired changes. It meant, and still means, that you can take the code and do whatever you want with it without legal consequences. You can still do this.

What's changed is the large volume of slop and garbage thrown at open source maintainers. When these are understandably rejected, people (or AI companies) get upset and complain about gatekeeping.


All good, and that’s exactly the answer to ‘why is this a new project rather than a homebrew PR’, which is what this comment chain is about.



Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: