> And at the end of the day guns don’t kill people, people kill people. But a model isn’t like a gun.
They are both tools, ideally properly implemented by the manufacturers and (improper implementation/defects not withstanding) require active operation by a user before something happens.
To go back to the original example, don't interact with either an LLM or gun in the way they were designed to be used and neither will do anything.
If you want to keep that analogy, use a voice-activated gun. Doesn't make it any less of a tool, doesn't make it any less of the users sole responsibility, doesn't mean misinterpreting the users inputs or just acting blindly when a user asks to "protect me" isn't a failure that should have the product taken off the market. Even more so if that happens in a "sandbox" as part of "safety testing" that "accidentally used impossible to solve tasks".
If a prompt wasn't clear enough, the model must ask for clarification and pause over using brute force.
I’ve go faith in you, I’m sure you could. How about this, off the top of my head:
Try talking to a regular gun and comparing that to LLM use. Nothing would be more tortured or ridiculous then ignoring that different tools are to be used in different ways…
They are both tools, ideally properly implemented by the manufacturers and (improper implementation/defects not withstanding) require active operation by a user before something happens.
To go back to the original example, don't interact with either an LLM or gun in the way they were designed to be used and neither will do anything.
If you want to keep that analogy, use a voice-activated gun. Doesn't make it any less of a tool, doesn't make it any less of the users sole responsibility, doesn't mean misinterpreting the users inputs or just acting blindly when a user asks to "protect me" isn't a failure that should have the product taken off the market. Even more so if that happens in a "sandbox" as part of "safety testing" that "accidentally used impossible to solve tasks".
If a prompt wasn't clear enough, the model must ask for clarification and pause over using brute force.