I don't like Israel TBH. I just don't need foreigners telling the American government who to arrest. The American law enforcement authorities should be following American laws and American court edicts.
While I don't agree, I would say your argument would be to ignore the ICC, not to sanction it. Why would we care if Benjamin Mileikowsky is arrested in Paris? We're doing exactly what you said you don't like: letting a foreign country (Israel) dictate our policy.
If Great Britain were to lay claim to Alaska, America would be totally within its right to sanction the UK. The ICC lays claim to jurisdiction over American citizens in violation of the sovereignty of the nation of the United States (which is, in the American understanding, in violation of the sovereignty of the people of the United States to rule themselves).
The ICC is free to operate as long as they don't claim to have jurisdiction over Americans living and doing stuff in America.
