Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm not sure what the point of vibe reading is when the announcement[1] is right there and explicitly calls out third party store support, being able to play "your PC games", and the fact that the device will run Windows. Could they backtrack on all this? Maybe, but it seems a bit too late for that.

The only thing I'm not certain of is the exact shape of the "exit button". It could be a "desktop app" like Windows 8 had, instead. Could be some way to add third party games to the Xbox launcher UI. Barely relevant, anyway.

[1]: https://news.xbox.com/en-us/2026/03/11/project-helix-buildin...

 help



> Could they backtrack on all this? Maybe, but it seems a bit too late for that.

So we're talking about taking a PC, which is a general purpose gaming platform able to use multiple stores equally, and giving Microsoft control over what can and can't run on it?

Of course Microsoft would backtrack, exactly as soon as the financial benefit to them outweighs the reputational cost.

They've been salivating over recurring revenue ever since Apple pivoted their model into leveraging hardware locking to privilege first party services.


"Giving Microsoft control" is a strange idea. If you are a DOS/Windows user (and to a large extent even if you aren't), then Microsoft was in control of the PC since the platform's inception and this doesn't change anything. Helix is a PC. Running an x86_64 CPU. It runs Windows (with some extra fluff that runs on boot), and someone will put some Linux or other on it eventually.

When I was talking about backtracking, I meant doing so before the release of the project, which would be reputation damage with no profit. And if it's out, as specified, then there's not really any backtracking to speak of anymore.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: