Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> It’s literally the worst in class. It feels very late 90’s Microsoft.

1. I was around in the 90’s; nothing today is that bad.

2. Siri AI is dramatically better than old-school Siri. You don’t realize how useful personal context is until you have it.

Something like “When was the last time I went to that pizza place downtown?”—it just works.

When you call the airline about your flight, your flight info automatically shows up.

 help



Yet something like "Call <name of a person>" will still immediately call someone with a completely different name without even letting me cancel, right?

Siri is completely useless.


Hah. Reminds me of carplay: "text (name)" "what would you like to know about (name)?" "f****** text them" dance daily while driving.

Just today: “give me directions to the ferry terminal”. I’m on an island with one terminal, I shouldn’t have to be specific.

“Here’s a list of three ferry terminals that are on different islands, none of which are the island you’re on.”

“Give directions to the Orcas Island ferry terminal.”

“Here’s directions to the Port of Orcas Island, which is on the side of the island opposite the ferry terminal.”

If I weren’t driving a camper van on narrow roads, I would have taken her up on the “other island” option. “How do you propose we get there, Siri? Maybe start by driving to the g-ddamned ferry terminal?!”


You might want to update your information a bit.

https://pogueman.substack.com/p/125-tests-of-the-new-ai-siri


Oh, nice, they added a confirmation screen before you call! I'm not sure when they're planning to roll that feature out to Europe but once they do, maybe Siri will be occasionally slightly useful when I need to call someone while my hands are dirty or while I'm driving.

I was around in the 90's too, which is why I can confidently say it is that bad. What Apple is doing with AI today is exactly the same formula as some of the worst stuff Microsoft put out back then. I'm not talking about the big things. More like the bundled apps where they see someone else getting traction with something and then they go and bundle their own K-Mart version of it that no one asked for.

> Something like “When was the last time I went to that pizza place downtown?”—it just works.

An absolute must have feature!

Just kidding. Couldn’t give a fuck about that.


> Siri AI is dramatically better than old-school Siri. [...] it just works.

Yeah, after 30 seconds, assuming it doesn't fail outright. The only thing I use Siri for is to set timers on my watch when cooking. This used to take 2-3 seconds at most and even worked completely offline on the watch itself. That functionality is now effectively broken for me.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: