Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

But it never starts doing anything until someone or something prompts it. It doesn’t even exist until you ask it to do something.

It is autonomous in the sense it can continue to function without supervision after the operator has started it, in the same way countless programs on your computer are “autonomous”.

But it can never choose to begin doing something at any time of its own volition. It does not have “autonomy” like a human does.

 help



Harnesses can schedule actions for later dates, and you might not notice.

Humans are not autonomous: they're not even your employees until you hire them. (This is what I understand you're saying about AI.)


how are humans autonomous by this definition then? did you ever do anything before you were born?

You are conflating creation and instruction. Your birth is analogous to the creation of an LLM model. Your subsequent actions are a consequent of your bodily compulsions, tampered by your environment. The LLMs actions are governed by what it is trained to perform. No one has full autonomy of their lives, but I would argue that LLMs have none at all.

> You are conflating

"It doesn’t even exist until you ask it to do something", not my words


We are autonomous because we have free will to choose our actions, and we may choose to do so at any time between our birth and death.

If you don’t believe in free will then nothing is autonomous.


Autonomous just means that a system is self-controlled rather than externally controlled. It is the name used for robots when they are wholly controlled by on-board software rather than external commands or remote control.

Something like NASA's Mars rovers are considered as semi-autonomous since they do receive external instructions, but then execute those instructions autonomously without further intervention. Similarly the combination of a coding agent and the LLM it connects to would best be considered as a semi-autonomous system.

You could also have a fully autonomous robot, or just agent, powered by an LLM, where it's not taking external instructions, but rather reacting to external events in some internally proscribed way.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: