Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This. I got strange looks when I discussed this issue with a few (non-technical) friends a while back. I said that Apps as they currently exist are more or less an interim solution. Sure, if you need to take pictures/videos it can be a useful thing to have a specialized app but most of the times a proper mobile webpage would suffice.

The only thing I am not so sure about when using your browser as your primary application container. What about UI/UX Guidelines. A well designed webapplication works for both ios/android users, but there still different UI paradigms in place.

Think of all the effort which is put in place to make for example java programs look native on the different systems.



"a proper mobile webpage would suffice"

I think people have higher aspirations than "would suffice".


Can you be specific? For example, what exactly would a mobile app of hacker news provide above and beyond what can easily be provided by a web site?


Websites should look, feel and behave like websites. Trying to imitate the native look and feel of an individual device/platform combination is bad. Just as it was bad to make horrible flash monstrosities that tried to pretend a webpage was a windows app.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: