I don't think he is saying that. Jeff Attwood is (I think) asking him to say "I approve, this is going to be a Markdown Spec" or "I disapprove" - in which case it will be a Rockdown Spec.
It seems to me that Gruber is adopting a 'Trotsky at Brest-Litovsk' position - "no war, no peace".
It seems to me that Gruber is adopting a 'Trotsky at Brest-Litovsk' position - "no war, no peace".