Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> for some reason, whole conversations get reset to a single timestamp.

What do you mean?





Submissions put in the second-chance pool briefly appear (sometimes "again") on the frontpage, and the conversation timestamps are reset so it appears like they were written after the second-chance submission, not before.

I never noticed that. What a weird lie!

I suppose they want to make the comments seem "fresh" but it's a deliberate misrepresentation. You could probably even contrive a situation where it could be damaging, e.g. somebody says something before some relevant incident, but the website claims they said it afterwards.


I think the reason is much simpler than that. Resetting the timestamp lets them easily resurface things on the frontpage, because the current time - posting time delta becomes a lot smaller, so it's again ranked higher. And avoiding adding a special case, lets the rest of the codebase work exactly like it was before, basically just need to add a "set submission time to now" function and you get the rest for free.

But, I'm just guessing here based on my own refactoring experience through the years, may be a completely different reason, or even by mistake? Who knows? :)


There is some action that moderators can take that throws one of yesterday's articles back on the front page and when that happens all the comments have the same timestamp.

I believe that this is called "the second chance pool." It is a bit strange when it unexpectedly happens to one's own post.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: