Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"Plug into right power socket"

Same language, opposite meaning because of a particular noun + context.

I think the only thing obvious here is that there is no obvious solution other than adding lots of clarification to your prompt.





I think you missed the entire point?

No, they just disagree with you.

How do you disagree with having a right and a left hand?

GP is using right as in “correct”, not directionality.

No, I don't think they are.

If you are facing a wall-plate with two power sockets on it side by side and you are telling someone to plug something in, which one would be "the right socket", and which would be "the left socket"?

If above the wall-plate is a photo of a person and you are someone to draw a tattoo on the photo, which is "the right arm" and which is "the left arm"?

Same wording, different expectation.


Power plugs are not people.

ETA: and if I were telling someone which socket to plug something into, it would absolutely be from the prospective of the person doing the plugging, not from inside the wall.


Neither are sculptures of skulls made of pancake batter.

> Power plugs are not people.

Agreed. So the "obvious" meaning of left and right differ depend on context, which is what pphysch was pointing out.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: