It's hardly even a polite ask. It's literally a text file. Automated http clients, such as search engine indexers (Google, yahoo, etc) are expected to use it to know what pages can be visited or not. That expectation is nothing more than a convention.
If you are on a Mac or Linux computer, odds are it has a program called curl pre-installed. If you type in curl website address in a terminal, it'll fetch make a request and download the response. Robot.txt never gets involved. Same is true for AI agents and search engines that aren't polite.
Regardless - requiring an account to read anything, even a "free" one, totally changes whole situation. Even when sites terms of service are limited by local law.
