Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

ooh I really like this one:

>* DIRECTED TAXES -- Software gains allow a certain portion of taxes to fall to the discretion of the payer. John Public can assign X amount of his taxes toward one service, to the exclusion of another. It's a second vote that politicians watch closely.



That would be an interesting experiment to conduct, although I fear the outcome slightly.

It would truly suck to not have any army should the need for one properly arise. As well, culture must lose in some form without galleries for art and dance, for instance.

Wonder how long it would take to set up a web app to test the theory...


eh negotiation works ~15x better than war (http://www.economist.com/world/international/displaystory.cf...)


As George Washington said, "to secure peace, we must always be prepared for war."

We all want peace, but to achieve it, we must be prepared for war- a well regulated militia and armed private citizens can go a long way toward this (and is essential), but a professional military is an important element,too.


Does it work when one side has no leverage because they defunded their military into extinction?


They still have people and can buy weapons with their superior economy.


I think states which pursue this strategy will find that with an aggressive enemy "just buy a competent military" is not something that you can accomplish in less than a generation.

How many European nations could "buy weapons" and then pull off a minor shooting war against a local tinpot dictator whose military budget would be lost in Toyota's R&D expenditures? (e.g. Save Kosovo... without calling the US.)

I think the answer to the rhetorical question is "exactly one", although I can name two others which would actually have the capability of showing up in time to drop a bomb or two, to no strategic effect. The others are universally incapable of even getting to the theatre.

And if Russia decided to get frisky and send in the tanks? Most nations in Europe would fold about as fast as Georgia did -- their sole means of defense is not being "acceptable, if regrettable, losses" in Washington.


You can always hire mercenaries.


I seem to recall that the reason mercenaries (at least in the US) are viable is because they hire ex-military. So most/all of the expensive training is done. Furthermore, mercenaries are not so good at things like air forces and carrier groups and artillery (v. large capital investments that lack adaptability to smaller situations).


Tell your senator to vote against subsidizing mercenaries with tax payers money!


As George Washington said, "to secure peace, we must always be prepared for war."

We all want peace, but to achieve it, we must be prepared for war- a well regulated militia and armed private citizens can go a long way toward this (and is essential), but a professional military is an important element,too.


That's a perfect example of the type of thinking I would worry about.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: