You're working as a collective consciousness. It's less impressive than it sounds.
You hear stuff from one of your trusted sources, and you repeat it. When you find something that can align with your discourse, you interact.
The point is that you all share "the same stuff", stuff I'm not interested in. It's the other way around, the mass of internet arguments you're a part of lacks the kind of stuff I have. That's why you're so drawn to it.
Relax, it's all mostly unconscious behavior. It's not about you specifically, more the swarm you belong to.
I'm not "working as a collective" or anything of the sort. I'm not part of any "swarm" either. I merely try to come to my own conclusions to the best of my ability based on the information available to me. It's not like I have insider access.