Not really. These other industries are evaluating people somehow. Whether it's vibes, connections, resume, or some sort of technical evaluation you'll have a grown adult evaluating you. Hiring will always feel a bit lame and arbitrary, you have limited time and information to pick someone. You're not going to be able to understand candidates fully and you'll probably pick wrong a fair bit. So we come up with criteria that's a bit arbitrary but you need at least some effort and smarts to meet them so it's at least a bit correlated with a good hire. I don't think the non technical methods are any more or less dignified.
