Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The author who is quoted in the article throwing someone else under the bus is especially gross (and very unbelievable),

> Faris denied she used AI in a post on Instagram and blamed a proofreader. “I wrote Rogue Souls entirely on myown [sic],” the April 17 post said. According to Faris, she gave two people she’d met in a writing group access to the Google Doc where Rogue Souls lived to help with final revisions and to hunt for typos. She said one of them used AI to fix sentences without her knowledge. “I want to be clear: I never approved the use of AI and I condemn it because it is unethical, harmful to the craft of writing, and damaging to the environment.”

> Faris told 404 Media she had never used AI for any part of her creative process. “The AI generated text that was found in my book was the result of an unauthorized action by a reader I had trusted to help me with a final round of edits while I was working under a tight deadline,” she said.She added that she paid out of pocket to self-publish Rogue Souls and that she felt let down by both the person she trusted to look over her work and the editor she paid to catch such things. “This experience has been a hard learned lesson,” she said. “I no longer share my manuscript with anyone. My trust in others has been permanently altered. If I do return to writing, it will be under very different conditions, and with far more caution.”



> final revisions

I.e. Subcontracting out part of the authorship, to some human. How much better is that than "hiring" an AI, directly, yourself?


Depending on the definition of final revisions, I don't think there is anything wrong with getting a second pair of eyes on something. Kinda like having someone review your PR?

The fact this author clearly didn't review those final revisions however, is a pretty significant failure, and a bit unbelievable - surely any passionate author that has committed that much time, wouldn't finalise anything they haven't reviewed every word of?


Show us the Google document changelogs if this is the case!


Great point. This would be very easy to prove.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: