Fwiw, the test for gifts under the tax code is payments motivated by "detached and disinterested generosity". So if you get something in return, it's hard for it to count as a gift. It doesn't have to even be a sale per se; for example, tipping at a restaurant is technically a voluntary payment for which you receive nothing in return, but it's not considered sufficiently detached/disinterested to count as a gift.
That's what I was arguing, that you can't classify something as a gift just because technically there is no exchange of consideration. Even though tips formally have no consideration, they still fail the detached/disinterested test, and count as income.