Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Fantastic.

I'll start posting stories about Hamas storing weapons in mosques, schools and hospitals. And firing rockets at civilian centres in Israel.

Then we'll have ourselves an old fashioned reddit party! first one to invoke godwin's law wins!!




When Hamas kills 1100 people you can.


It's all so simple and one sided isn't it?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Hamas_suicide_attacks

Seriously let's have a debate on this. This being a hacker forum is the perfect place to do it isn't it?


I'm not supporting Hamas and am not supporting any attacks against civilians from either side. But you also have to look at what has happened the last 60 years. Israel is not without blood on their hands either.

Let's face it. The last 60 years have been a disaster for the Middle East, and any action from either side can be "justified" with pointing at something the other side has done.

There have been attempts to make peace, but there have been too many demands that the other side can't accept. This can only be solved by one of the sides letting history be history and try to make a real attempt at peace. I think Israel, as the dominant party, should withdraw to the borders of 1967 and that the Palestinians should accept a multi-national peace keeping force that would stabilize the region and prevent further attacks on Israel.

It might take a couple of generations for the two sides to forgive each other, but it is worth a try.


Look, my point is not one way of the other (although I do have strong opinions on the matter.) My point is that when you mix politics and controversy in an anonymous public forum, you get a lot more heat than light.

I'm amazed that this story hasn't been killed yet (it really seems to go against a lot of previous editorial decisions here, which I thought were a really good idea.) Can you imagine a story about Hamas using human shields on the front page? it would be nuts, whether you think it's an important issue or not. These kinds of stories are a magnet for trolls.


These kinds of stories are a magnet for trolls.

And yet...

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=438654

So why can't the discussion continue? Why aren't Israel and Hamas's actions viable targets of inquiry?


Just as you can run across a busy highway once, twice, or ten times and come out fine, doesn't mean that's it's a good idea, so allowing one story like this won't cause much damage, but as an editorial policy is a disaster.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: