Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

surprisingly people do love to work.

Although I have a masters degree I worked for 10 years, 3 nights each week, as a volunteer psychotherapist, providing free therapy to those that could least afford psychotherapy, those that needed it most.

I obviously had a day job too. I loved working for free, the benefits are huge, less stress and autonomy in how you choose to spend your time and skills and a greater sense of achievement.

If I had CBI I would work for free.

I am all for social devotional work backed with CBI.

CBI and work for free if you want to.

I can definitetely understand the sense of feeling more mentally stable without the daily stresses that come with not enough money to live on.

Most people who earn a decent salary are generally against CBI because of their own values around their own working ethic. There is nothing written anywhere that says that work is beneficial to a human being.

The money for nothing crowd always raises its ugly head when talking about any support that benefits human development especially of the poor.

As a retired therapist the majority of my lower socio-economic clients problems where due in full to the finanacial situation they found themselves in.

All therapists carry a sense of helplessnes when dealing with such clients becaue we cannot help them.



>Most people who earn a decent salary are generally against CBI because of their own values around their own working ethic. There is nothing written anywhere that says that work is beneficial to a human being.

I'm not against UBI, I just don't see how it can be done. It seems fundamentally impossible to finance at scale, which all of these experiments ignore. They are always experiments where a tiny number of people get money generated by a vast majority of people.

Which we have already, in the form of needs-based welfare.


People love meaning and purpose in their life and they typically find that in work as its a complex amalgamation of all sorts of challenges and rewards.

I believe UBI would be a net benefit for society it would enable the poorest to survive better and the rest of us more flexibility in how we life our lives.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: