Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The comment (despite protests to the contrary) injected politics unnecessarily and a bit randomly (there’s no particular reason to believe Intel and the US government are very similar).



> (there’s no particular reason to believe Intel and the US government are very similar)

Large monopolies with limited market pressure to innovate?


Not really, no. Governments aren’t businesses. There isn’t much of a market for governance, people mostly become citizens by birth instead of by shopping around.

Governments have natural “monopoly” over their territory (if there is competition for governing inside a territory, you have a civil war going on).

Or, there is no monopoly, since you can “shop around” by moving to other countries. It depends on how you want to line up the analogy. (There’s room to line up the analogy in multiple ways because it is an analogy, and not a description of what countries actually are).

Governments don’t innovate much on governance. They might enable innovation in other sectors. But the process of governance itself should generally be pretty slow-and-steady because the stakes are higher than an individual business. The goal of a government is not to create new and interesting governance-products and then sell those products, but to rule over an area in a way that doesn’t annoy the populace too much.


How are the concepts of a state and a business the same?


Also they both own real estate?

Not all things that share some attributes are similar in general.


My shirt today is red. Do you know what else is red? Those buses in London!


Hah. Not even, though. Redness is a characteristic that means the same thing in the context of your shirt and a bus. Because there isn’t generally a competitive market for the service of “being governed” monopoly doesn’t even make sense there.

It is more like saying strawberries and ethyl methylphenylglycidate are both red tasting.


Fair point. Is that what they put in Code Red? Because that drink tastes damn red.


I dunno it was the first thing I came across for artificial strawberry flavor, haha.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: