Ask HN: Review my site Skuttlefish - rate videos second by second

[freddy]

http://www.skuttlefish.com

Skuttlefish was envisioned while watching CNN conduct those Dial Polls during the Presidential debates. Basically this very beta service will allow you to enter a video url (YouTube only for now) and rate the video as it is playing on a scale from 0 -> 10 for positive and 0 -> -10 for negative. We also store this information to provide historic data. If you bring up a video you can click on historic data points to be taken directly to a specific point in the video.

As I mentioned it is very beta, with lots of plans in the works for widgets, more video formats, comments, etc.

Let me know what you think.

[pclark]

Hah. Cool.

Few niggles:

* The slider only rates when you "click" - as in, I assumed I could drag the slider up/down as the video played and it'd rate it in real time. That'd be cool.

* Work on your homepage! Include: Search for YouTube Videos, Highest rated/Lowest rated videos. "Think of Skuttlefish as Dial Polls for online videos. " I don't know what this means, personally. I'd make the "What is Skuttlefish" text much larger and colourful, its a cool idea so make sure users know what they're doing the moment they look at the page.

* Make a logo. Make a bookmarklet so I can rate YouTube videos from Youtube.com

* When I explicitly click "Register" it takes me to the login window. Can you make it so you can login with your "name" or email?

[pclark → pclark]

I hope that didnt come across as too harsh, I really think its a fantastic idea, and I think your execution is great - just a few TINY niggles! You've done 99.999% of the work!

[freddy → pclark]

oh no no that is exactly what I was looking for. Thank you for your comments I will add to them right away. Do you think it is a workable concept?

[pclark → freddy]

I think so! I think the trick is to allow users to use it from the youtube.com site -- make it really really easy to rate videos. You almost want some form of bot that posts a comment on users video page if they're rated x times ("your video has been ranked on skuttlefish - the most popular part is y, and the least popular is z - rate this video here")

[freddy → pclark]

nice idea.

[freddy → pclark]

yeah it should do it when the slider stops, so if it starts at 0 and you move it to 5 and stop, then it should place a rating at 5. is this happening for you?

[pclark → freddy]

it works for me when the slider stops and I release dragging, is that what it should do?

[freddy → pclark]

yes exactly that is how it should work.

[pclark → freddy]

working A-OK then :) I assumed you could just keep dragging the slider up/down and it'll update my rating.