Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

So many sites don't have a reject button immediately parallel to the accept button on the main consent management screen.



Sure, mostly non EU or non big business sites.

The non EU sites are due to the EU trying to claim global jurisdiction.

The EU are very much to blame for the popups, because even the non dark-patterns one are annoying.


> Sure, mostly non EU or non big business sites.

Nope, including EU big business sites as well. There are also EU big business sites which illegally claim the legitimate interest basis for advertising and tracking purposes of data processing which have already been ruled by the courts as not acceptable justifications for the legitimate interest basis.

> The non EU sites are due to the EU trying to claim global jurisdiction.

The EU is trying to protect the data of the people in the EU. There's no way to do that while allowing companies outside the EU to freely violate the privacy of people in the EU. Otherwise these rules become laughably easy to circumvent for all but the smallest EU companies which are also the least dangerous from a privacy and tracking perspective.

> The EU are very much to blame for the popups, because even the non dark-patterns one are annoying.

Disagree. They're not supposed to be annoying enough to impair site usability. The truly compliant ones aren't.


> Nope, including EU big business sites as well.

Maybe some, but generally businesses are not breaking the law willy nilly like that.

> There are also EU big business sites which illegally claim the legitimate interest basis for advertising and tracking purposes of data processing which have already been ruled by the courts as not acceptable justifications for the legitimate interest basis.

And did the EU follow up?

> The EU is trying to protect the data of the people in the EU.

The problem is it's unenforceable nonsense and has led to this foolish cookie popup situation.

If they had limited it to entities with a presence in the EU, it would have worked better. At the moment it applies to some malicious Chinese teenager who blatantly wants to collect and sell the data of Europeans who visit his self-hosted low-traffic blog.

> The truly compliant ones aren't.

Yeah, they really are. It's still something you have to interact with to make it go away.

If your response says something if companies don't track they won't need a popup, then you have missed the point.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: