I agree that balance is necessary and nitpickers should be steered away from that behaviour.
I think I'm more concerned with nitpickers which show up in different flavours.
I understand a functional requirement to rewrite a piece of code in a PR. Perhaps you spent the last 8 hours coding up a solution that passes all of the tests but if you use that data structure at scale it wouldn't perform acceptably. That's a rewrite and that sucks but it will be for the better.
I think I'm more concerned with nitpickers which show up in different flavours.
I understand a functional requirement to rewrite a piece of code in a PR. Perhaps you spent the last 8 hours coding up a solution that passes all of the tests but if you use that data structure at scale it wouldn't perform acceptably. That's a rewrite and that sucks but it will be for the better.