Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

One question I've always had with this: How does the rotation of the earth affect an airplane's flight time, if any? And how does this change with altitude?



Simple answer: Zero. Because the planes move inside the atmosphere, which moves with the earth.

A more nuisance would be that earth rotating generate all sorts of things in the atmosphere, including winds and Coriolis effect on the winds, and you can account for that considering the winds. Btw a flight from Chile to France and back, will have a leg significantly shorter (up to 2 hs in a 13hs flight) and which leg it is, depends on the time of the year.


Interesting to know about the Coriolis effect.

I get that what really matters is the relative motion, but it still seems to me that there might be a gravitational/inertial effects at play, even if tiny.

Consider this thought experiment: Planes cannot really fly into space, but assume they can. At a certain altitude, it cannot be said the the plane is moving perfectly in step with the gravity of the earth. At infinite altitude, that certainly cannot be the case.

So that tells me there is some deviation due to the inertia of the plane, even at low altitudes. Like I said, the effect might be tiny, but would be interesting to learn more about it nonetheless.


I meant coriolis effect on the wind. Not sure if noticeable in a plane.


In general, the air moves with the ground, so the earth's rotation does not affect airplanes.

However, rotation of the earth imparts a coriolis force on the air, which results in jetstream winds. Aircraft routes are optimized to use/avoid jetstreams for shorter travel times.


It does not really, at least not directly. What matters is relative velocity compared to the starting and final locations, and relative to the air around the aircraft. It just happens that there are very powerful atmospheric currents that go west to east (those are due to the earth’s rotation, among others phenomena).

So, when flying towards the east, catching these currents can significantly reduce flying time. When flying towards the west, we want to avoid them by flying below or elsewhere.


Thanks for this explanation; quite interesting.

But it still seems to me that there might be a gravitational/inertial effects at play as well. At a (hypothetical) infinite altitude, it can no longer be said the the plane is moving perfectly in lock-step with the gravity/rotational acceleration of the earth. This implies the inertia of the plane relative to the rotation of the earth still has an effect at lower altitudes.

The effect might be tiny, but would be interesting to learn more about it nonetheless.


What gravity/rotational acceleration ?

Something like this does exist under general relativity :

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frame-dragging

However,

> This does not happen in Newtonian mechanics for which the gravitational field of a body depends only on its mass, not on its rotation.


Yes frame-dragging seems to be the name of the concept I was thinking of. Cool.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: