Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

This deserves a much more thought out and nuanced answer than I am capable to give.

I will try anyway.

Let's take something that we have more information about: burnout. Since burnout is a hot button topic, we're all somewhat aware about it.

Many people misconstrue burnout to mean "overworked" - which it's not, it's a type of depression where your emotional investment is not getting adequate emotional returns: and that's what's happening with your depiction of "bitter".

You had objectively worse situations happening to you, yes! However- the conditions in which they happened were:

* Not artificial. There was no concerted effort by the universe to conspire to give your fathers cancer.

* You were given sympathy

* You were given the opportunity to actually air grievances about it before it boiled up- likely you were told that it's healthy to feel bad or to express yourself.

Likewise, bitterness is the culmination of being treated in a way you perceive as unfair, and it starts small. It gets worse when not treated. Treatment is as easy as letting people be a little angry sometimes or to let them talk about their issues and be met with something other than condescension.

You had a worse situation, yes, but you're talking about people getting moody as a moral failing.

It would be like me telling a woman not to be moody on her period because some men have their arms blown off on oil rigs. They're not comparable at all.






You misunderstood me. I very explicitly do not think it is a moral failing at all. I do not have any problem with someone being moody. Problems aren’t a competition. I mentioned mine not to imply that mine were worse, but just that they were different, and to show that I wasn’t speaking from a position of “having no problems” or being oblivious to them.

It is completely reasonable to be bitter. But long-term, it is still a choice.

I don’t disagree that being bitter, at the onset, is not a choice. And often requires treatment.

Burnout is a great example because I agree with everything you said about it. Becoming bitter when burnt out isn’t a choice. Staying bitter is.

For short periods, it is almost always even necessary; treatment requires feeling.

But too many people get stuck in it, do not seek treatment (or are afraid to / taught not to, even amongst friends), and do not move forward. Even that is still not a moral failing; but it does make me sad.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: