Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

But this whole conversation could be much more interesting if, instead of presenting a critical analysis of the language used by pro- or anti-immigration groups, some policies were discussed.

For example, one might say that undocumented people with no criminal records who have been here for more than x years, would be given documents. All the others will be deported. Then, one might discuss the merits of x years instead of z years, but it would be a starting point.

"I don't know of many/anyone that's in favor of illegal immigration" -- all those who are against deporting illegals, support illegal immigration. One cannot say with a straight face, well, I am of course against illegal immigration, but since they are already here..."Sure, I am against homicides but since the guy is already dead..."






> instead of presenting a critical analysis of the language used by pro- or anti-immigration groups, some policies were discussed.

> "I don't know of many/anyone that's in favor of illegal immigration" -- all those who are against deporting illegals, support illegal immigration.

An example of the reason there is critical analysis of language used is due to exactly what was done right here.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: