Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm a senior developer. Of course I know how to code. Do you know how many code challenges I've done over the course of my career? 99% of them where terrible at evaluating my ability to code. They are a waste of time at the senior level. You are much better off with a conversation, looking at past work and experience and references than you are doing code challenges.


After interviewing ~50 people using this technique - I'm sorry but there's no "of course". I cannot tell by looking at your past work experience or talking to you whether you know how to code.

I know this, because I used to look at resumes and have long conversations before I ran my pairing interview. And I found the results almost uncorrelated. Now I save the fun conversations for people who make it through the screening. But by then I already know if I want to hire them.

My pairing interview (it's a pairing session, not a code challenge) covers aspects of engineering that I specifically care about. It's not terribly hard. But at the end I'll have a pretty good idea if I want to turn this person loose in my codebase.


I second all of that heartily. Of course the senior eng with 10 years hands-on experience at a household name tech company knows how to code... except that they don't. At all, apparently. That seems so ludicrously unlikely unless you've actually interviewed a lot of people, then it's just the sad fact.

To others reading along, I'm not talking about someone not being able to write a multitasking OS on their own. I mean, I'm not sure how these people possibly graduated college not knowing how to write a trivial program in the language of their choosing. Turns out you can get surprisingly far into a software engineering degree without every writing code. I wouldn't have believed it. Evidence proves it though.


Based on my interviewing, there's a ~25% likelihood that you're flat out lying, and a ~75% likelihood that you're overstating your skills.

The number of people with impressive looking resumes, and good command of the jargon, but who still can't successfully code hello world is shocking.

I don't believe you (general you, not just the parent) can even code until you demonstrate that to me, or until the industry comes up with a reputable way to tell me that you can code. Until then I'll be making sure you can at least write code that compiles and finishes a brain-dead simple task.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: