Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> For large organizations, remote can be the difference between one state's paperwork + regs + taxation, and every state and country under the sun's paperwork + regs + taxation. That is a real burden. Not just the paperwork + administrative overhead, but being subject to differing employment + everything else laws from everywhere will really muck up ability to run a consistent business.

This is a real burden for small businesses. The nature of Amazon's business as an online retailer with a massive distribution network means that for any significant market they do business in, they will have employees. Practically speaking, this is a solved problem for any state in which Amazon has a warehouse (which I think is probably all of them for the US?).




All major payroll companies and employment law firms have long since figured out paperwork, taxes, and labor regulations in all 50 states. Unless you're so small that you don't even have an external payroll provider or legal counsel, "differences between States" shouldn't be a valid excuse.


While Amazon may have the administrative capacity for handling the filings, that doesn't address the tax revenue politics + considerations (which i didn't write much about in my earlier comment).

The issue of state tax breaks was such a big deal during their "HQ2" contest a few years ago that it actually became one of the top issues in the NYC elections that year. (to a large extent local candidate races became a referendum on how they felt about giving tax breaks to amazon in exchange for Amazon's commitments to employ a certain # of highly paid software + product people who would potentially contribute to the overall tax base. NYC people ended up electing politicians to stop the previously-negotiated pending deal with amazon, and amazon got enough blowback to say 'we give up' publicly.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: