Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

My reaction to your use of "fucking" wasn't that it appalled me in some moralistic or linguistic sense. Rather, I felt like it (partially) undermined the point of your post.

The post is about how being CEO isn't all glamor, and includes doing dirty work as well. And you make clear that you feel the janitor, unlike a figurehead who merely signs documents, contributes something useful and necessary to the enterprise.

Unfortunately, denigrating the janitor by tagging the role as "fucking" just buys into the CEO-as-glamorous-leader mindset that the post argues against. It transforms the title from a correction ("You think you are the CEO, but in reality you are in charge of the dirty work") into a put-down ("You think you are the CEO, but in reality you are the lowest of the low.")

Yes, it sounds stronger-- but, in my mind, it shades your meaning in ways you probably don't intend.




The fuck.

What is up with this opinion? Fuck means sex. Why do we call these words obscene? Do you honestly think those words entered daily use? "Grab the fucking milk" said without any emotional meaning. People would actually reason more.

It's a prohibition on words, that makes them mean more artificially while contributing no logic to the discussion.

How dare ye try to elate an emotion in me! How dare ye!

Edit:I'm an idiot and wrote an argument to something you didn't say, but I'll leave it here cause it took me 5 minutes to write on the phone keyboard.


> Edit:I'm an idiot and wrote an argument to something you didn't say, but I'll leave it here cause it took me 5 minutes to write on the phone keyboard.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunk_costs#Loss_aversion_and_th...

EDIT: In other words, it's even more idiotic to leave it here after you've determined it was a mu post.


Hey I'm happy to live in a world of honest assholes.


Yeah, its the dishonest ones that fuck it up for everyone else.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: