Winamp 3, as an application, got it all right. Software developers even today struggle to get applications to be so usable.
Dead simple interface
Super fast start up
Super fast search
Easy playlist creation and management
Simple keyboard shortcuts
Simple configuration
Huge library of plugins
Zero distractions
Stable
I still miss winamp. To this day there hasn't been another media player that just got completely out of my way and let me listen to music.
It sounds like you are describing Winamp 2. As I recall (and the article seems to confirm) Winamp 3 added no useful features while killing stability and speed. I do remember liking winamp 5 (there was no 4) though.