Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Whole point of the digital face is to look real though, and freezing the gaze would look unnervingly fake.



I'm confident they could come up with a filler eye animation algorithm that was convincing enough to pass muster for short periods of time. Even if hand coding something didn't quite work out, they certainly have tons of eye tracking data internally they could use to train a small model, or optimize parameters.


The complexity of this solution just shot up from "2 minute hack" to "2 month research project, minimum". It's understandable why they didn't do this.


I don't think anyone was suggesting to go for the 'parameterized model' from the start. They could just hide the eyes while typing, as a good starting point.


Yeah. Make them appear closed, done


No way this takes two months to get to a convincing proof of concept.


But you could at least dampen out or randomize eye travel while looking at the keyboard. Fully reproducing eye output is a recipe for disaster, and that should have been obvious.


It's about tradeoffs, the device is barely 7 months old at this point. Thankfully the fix is fairly obvious too.


OTOH once you as an outsider know that sometimes the AVP is lying to you about where the wearer is looking why would you ever trust it?

For example, you could then use the AVP to stare at people and then claim afterwards you were doing no such thing.


Add a faint glow to indicate they're typing and the continued face animation is a stand-in.


Throw people for a loop and switch your headset keyboard to DVORAK. When they scan your eye movements and apply to QWERTY, they'll be confused AF!


Well, you still only have to try one other password. If you get locked out after one password attempt and nobody knows that you use dvorak, your defense works, but if you have three attempts, you can also add colemak to your list of things to try ;)


add sunglasses to the avatar while typing


Someone hire this person please.


Just have them close their eyes? That's what I do when I have to recall my password anyway.


Just do the same thing the external display does and do a 'cloudy eyes' version when they user is interacting w/ the keyboard.


If I were implementing it and wanted to obscure, I'd blur the whole screen momentarily, probably with a small message. I really doubt that's ideal for a commercial offering, though. I'm not really worried about unnerving people if I'm using an avatar, that comes with the territory as it is.


Why? Most people are capable of fixating at a single point with basically no perceptible eye movement.


It would, wouldn't it?

I'd suggest blurring the face in a "password input context" (like password fields on the web with their redacted display text), but I suspect that that'd go against what Apple wants the Vision Pro experience to look like.


Then it shouldn't be used for secure input.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: