Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

You may have a uncommon idea of non-technical people. Such folks don’t know what a list view even is, and would have to have it explained. Not to mention a filesystem.



I told them something like "I'm going to show you an app showing files as a bunch of icons, can you try to make it show the files as a list instead?".

You seem to be very skeptical - did you try asking someone around you and got a different result?


Yes—we can see it's a suboptimal design on its face.[1] Bunch of repetitive dots and lines, with misleading clues. Not everyone is going to respond to it the same way of course. Some folks don't bother with clues.

The main point is that this problem has been solved already, better and in the past, by products delivered to tens of millions of seats. Merely copying prior art would have sufficed.

Responding with, "I found some non-techies who didn't have a problem" is not a direct response to the idea that the design could be improved. Folks can persevere and ultimately succeed through poor designs... in fact we all do it every day.

Some of us would like to use products that are a little more thoughtful than the bare minimum attainable-through-perseverance functionality, however.

[1] https://ux.stackexchange.com/questions/1795/when-to-use-icon...


That's a very long and quite condescending way to say you actually didn't ask anyone.


Already been studied at length. There are citations at that link and more a search away.

Tone-policing makes for a boring discussion as well.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: