Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I can’t see why it couldn’t be recycled? Though I think the most important issue would be its suitability to its intended use case. Recyclability would be somewhere down the list.



Because most alloys are damn hard to separate. Aluminum is very abundant on earth and we can recycle it to the infinity only with energy, so together with glass is a key element of a circular economy, unfortunately pure aluminum is next to useless, and alloys are hard to recover, that's why I ask. We can recover some of them, avional for instance, but many others are damn hard.


How are alloys a worse source of pure aluminium than natural deposits? Are natural deposits available where the aluminium is very pure once you squint hard enough to not see anything else in the mix that has sufficiently different properties to be easily shareable?


It's a matter of easiness of separations: in natural deposits you have to process much material to get a little quantity of mineral, but getting a pure enough mineral is still easy.

Separating alloys it's often much harder because alloy component tend to change phase together (so you can make them liquid, but you still have no way to separate when they are liquid) chemical bonds keeps them together. For some it's easy, let's say you add a substance that separate them, or heat separate them because they change from solid to liquid at different temperatures and so on, for many others it's complicated enough you recover little quantity of the original material spending too much in the process.


Thanks. So an ore with a high aluminium content that also has some amount of e.g. iron (I read that as an example in another comment?) would be worse than an ore with much less aluminium, but where everything else is "more different". Or where it actually does contain a multitude of metals that would be inconvenient in an alloy, but that happen to be bound to different "carriers" that are easy to separate before splitting the molecules. Interesting. Really makes one admire the geological processes that gave us those convenient ores.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: