> the fact that there is a standardized test in my mind does the opposite and makes the process much fairer.
It can make the process fairer but it's not a given. You can do the classic "no dogs, no blacks no Irish," and that was a standard across pubs in England. It certainly wasn't fair, unless you were racist.
If you're committed to fairness, then a standard will help. It gives you a clear point to fix and improve things and something you can use to measure if you're achieving your stated goals. That's definitely something you can't do if you're just making things up as you go along.
And yes, I made a deliberately provocative statement. I'm obviously not saying whiteboard tests are the equivalent of segregation.
It can make the process fairer but it's not a given. You can do the classic "no dogs, no blacks no Irish," and that was a standard across pubs in England. It certainly wasn't fair, unless you were racist.
If you're committed to fairness, then a standard will help. It gives you a clear point to fix and improve things and something you can use to measure if you're achieving your stated goals. That's definitely something you can't do if you're just making things up as you go along.
And yes, I made a deliberately provocative statement. I'm obviously not saying whiteboard tests are the equivalent of segregation.