Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Your example is nonsensical. There are minimum wage laws. And if somebody is not getting paid at all, then of course they are fired. You've completely changed the example to where they clearly are fired, so I don't know what you're trying to argue.

> This is also not in any contract that I've ever signed

Are you sure you've looked? It can also be implicit in standard clauses such as the company owns all rights to all of your work. In which case starting a second job would be fraudulent.

But of course it's also one of those things that's so common sense it doesn't need to be written into a contract in at-will employment countries (although it often is). There's the expectation in a full-time salaried professional job that the employer is getting all your productive professional work. It's mentally impossible to give 100% to two full-time jobs simultaneously. There's no reasonable expectation that anyone should be able to hold a second full-time CEO job. Nobody is "changing the terms" when the terms are commonly understood. If you start showing up to work shirtless and it wasn't in your employment contract that you're required to wear a top, complaining that they're "changing the terms" is missing the point entirely.




Considering a shit ton of employees in SV are working on their own projects in their spare time, start their own companies, and moonlight - I don't think this is as common in contracts as you're making it out to be.

The example is in the headline.


No, a great deal of that is explicitly prohibited.

If you work for Google, they own anything you develop on the side. They're actually nice in that they have a review process where they will give you your rights back if they decide it isn't competitive with any of their lines of business.

A lot of other companies don't even provide that. If you start a business on the side, they own all of its IP. Period.

This is extremely common. Both with large corporations as well as with startups. You just might not be aware of it.


It is extremely not common, lol.

I’ve done startups myself and it’s not common in any contracts I’ve signed nor have my coworkers. If it was, we all wouldn’t be able to start our own companies.


It is less common at start ups, especially startups from certain cultures / geographic regions.

However, it can be fairly common at larger companies, especially in specific segments.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: