Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I find this decision to put it in the iPad Pro somewhat puzzling. One consequence of this is that nobody is going to want to buy M3 MacBooks for a while, knowing that such a big leap in performance is around the corner.

Does Apple really sell more iPad Pros than MacBooks to make it worthwhile? I was under the impression that the iPad Pro is a somewhat niche product and the Air is far more popular.




> One consequence of this is that nobody is going to want to buy M3 MacBooks for a while, knowing that such a big leap in performance is around the corner.

I think this is one of those things that only enthusiasts care about, and if you care that much about performance you’re probably one of the people who buys a new one every year or two anyways so they aren’t really missing out on your revenue.

Most people just need or want a new laptop and order whatever one is currently available.


I think the theory is that there is going to be a large on-device AI push at WWDC. And iPads generally have a very long refresh cycle. In order for iPads to participate, they needed the M4's.


I think it makes total sense. I speculate the M4 might be too expensive to manufacture for a MBA right now. The iPad Pro is a relatively niche, slow cycle and high-margin product.

People who buy MacBooks aren't suddenly going to stop or switch to Windows because of some Osborne effect. The entry-level M3 MBA is still extremely hard to beat at the same price point.


They mentioned during the presentation that they need the new display controller on the M4 to drive the new dual panel display.


Interestingly that probably means having proper support for 2 external displayport on MBA as well, I'd assume...


That's really an underrated part of the announcement. It sounds like they're moving the entire display TCON on-chip.


> One consequence of this is that nobody is going to want to buy M3 MacBooks for a while

Like how long? M4 MacBook Pros could in theory launch in a month (i.e. WWDC). That's worthwhile.


I believe that refreshed MacBooks are not expected at WWDC and there may be quite a wait as we are mid-cycle.


> I believe that

Most believed that M4 was not coming either until a last minute rumor. So who knows.

Related rumors: - M3 process is expensive so it's getting dropped ASAP - M4 needed for AI so the whole line is getting refreshed - There's competition from Nuvia etc and M4 is needed to get ahead


M3s are also in mid-cycle. Or rather, they were.


the ipad is not a replacement for macbooks so the assumption is not correct.

I think it's more likely that current owners of m3 macbooks will be enticed to buy m4 ipads and thus apple makes more money.

And owners of older macbooks would buy both the m3 macbook and the m4 ipad

It sounds backwards, but that's how the apple ecosystem works.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: