Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Devil's advocate: RAM on SOCs is not upgradable due to technical limitations on frequency and latency needing the RAM chips to be as close as possible to the CPU. You can't beat physics.

I do hold them accountable for the non-upgradable SSDs, which are not needed to be soldered to achieve their full speed, and slim PCB connectors for PCI-E speed connections do exist.




Devil's advocate: sell replacement drop-in boards and reuse the chassis.

Are they still fusing displays into lids on the "pro" level MacBook?


Or better yet, sell the stacked SOC + RAM modules. Any good repair shop can replace BGA devices.


>Devil's advocate: sell replacement drop-in boards and reuse the chassis.

Apple's response if regulators push for that: "Sure, that'll be 1600$ for the board please. (on an 1800$ new machine). Oh, and BTW, the board is paired to your iCloud account so you can't then re-sell it on the used market, for your own protection of course. You're welcome."


The topic was what Apple would do voluntarily if they cared about the environment.


> Devil's advocate: RAM on SOCs is not upgradable due to technical limitations on frequency and latency needing the RAM chips to be as close as possible to the CPU. You can't beat physics.

What about LPCAMM2? https://www.theverge.com/2024/5/7/24151369/lpcamm2-laptop-me...


That just came out, let's see if it goes anywhere and if they keep pushing it in other products, or if it's just a marketing exercise for one product, but I'm skeptical its here to stay.

I also remember how upgradable GPUs in laptops using MMX slots were pushed by Dell and a couple of others a few times 10-15 years ago, but abandoned each time.

I hope this catches on though, but like I said, I'm skeptical.


That's still several times farther from the CPU than a memory die placed directly on top of it.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: