Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Somewhat true but things are changing. While there are plenty of “luxury” Apple devices like Vision Pro or fully decked out MacBooks for web browsing we no longer live in a world where tech are just lifestyle gadgets.

I notice your use of the weasel word "just".

We undoubtedly live in a world where Apple products are sold as lifestyle gadgets. Arguably it's more true today than it ever was. It's also a world where Apple's range of Veblen goods managed to gain footing in social circles to an extent that we have kids being bullied for owning Android phones.

Apple's lifestyle angle is becoming specially relevant because they can no longer claim they sell high-end hardware, as the difference in specs between Apple's hardware and product ranges from other OEMs is no longer noticeable. Apple's laughable insistence on shipping laptops with 8GB of RAM is a good example.

> Even in the higher end products like the MacBooks you see a lot of professionals (engineers included) who choose it because of its price-performance-value, and who don’t give a shit about luxury.

I don't think so, and that contrasts with my personal experience. All my previous roles offered a mix of MacBooks and windows laptops, and MacBooks were opted by new arrivals because they were seen as perks and the particular choice of windows ones in comparison were not as impressive, even though they out-specced Apple's offering (mid-range HP and Dell). In fact in a recent employee's review their main feedback was that the MacBook pro line was under-specced because at best it shipped with only 16GB of RAM while the less impressive HP ones already came with 32GB. In previous years, they called for the replacement of the MacBook line due to the rate of keyboard malfunctions. Meaning, engineers were purposely picking the underperforming option for non-technical reasons.




I bought my first Apple product roughly 11 years ago explicitly because it had the best accessibility support at the time (and that is still true). While I realize you only see your slice of the world, I really cringe when I see the weasel-word "lifestyle". This "Apple is for the rich kids"-fairytale is getting really really old.


Apparently you’ve never used Apple Silicon. There’s no PC equivalent in terms of specs.

Also, I think you’re misunderstanding what a Veblen good is and the difference between “premium” and “luxury.” Apple does not create luxury or “Veblen” goods like for example, LVMH.

An easy way to discern the difference between premium and luxury — does the company advertise the product’s features or price?

For example, a Chanel handbag is almost entirely divorced from its utility as a handbag. Chanel doesn’t advertise features or pricing, because it’s not about the product’s value or utility, it’s what it says about your personal wealth that you bought it. That’s a Veblen good.

Apple heavily advertises features and pricing. Because they sell premium products that are not divorced from their utility or value.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: