Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I find the idea of lab grown meat almost comical…

So we have these animals, which eat plants and generate fuel (poop) & food (meat). Our bodies are adapted to eating them, our bodies need the same nutrients, and we’re programmed to enjoy the food. The input to this process is mostly grass and grain, both generated via solar power.

Now instead… we take grain, highly process it and make someone few people enjoy, with less nutrients, and likely some unforeseen by products. They can then sell it at a higher price.

At the end of the day, we know what works. It doesn’t make sense to try and reinvent the wheel without benefit.




Lab-grown meat is meat, not grain. It's produced in bioreactors and the like. It doesn't really exist in any meaningful sense yet, though.


It also has to have some inputs, which come from things like grain.

The more interesting part, is imo there will be a lot of nutrition we miss


Much meat already uses grain as a substantial part of its input already...


I know, that's my point. We already have a highly efficient and nutritious way to obtain meat.


Well, it’s not highly efficient, at all, except maybe chicken. The feed ratio (how much food it takes to get one unit of meat) on animals ranges pretty widely. Cows are an order of magnitude more than chicken, with pigs in the middle.

A lot of time, energy, and land goes to just keeping the animal alive and metabolizing. And you’re left with the problem of a lot of the parts of the animal are of low value.

Lab grown meat could, in theory, be much more efficient. Just quickly grow the muscles people actually want to eat.

There are also a lot of potential ethical issues with the way meat is raised at scale.

However the comment implying it’s an option currently is ridiculous. It’s nowhere near ready for scale. Might as well cite that Star Trek meal thingy (replicator?).


I’d find your take on the matter almost comical if it weren’t so misinformed.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: